Brute Reason

A collection of thoughts about psychology, social justice, and anything else I give a shit about.

http://freethoughtblogs.com/brutereason

Topics: feminism / psychology / lgbtq / sex / politics / abortion / health / mental illness / language / depression / sexism / sexual assault / fashion / racism / education

latining:

Some Musicals Are More Feminist Than Others : Ms. Magazine Blog

ozyreads:

brute-reason:

Great piece about Les Mis.

I dunno, I find the statement that the majority of women are forced into sex work suspect. In the sense of trafficking, I’m pretty sure that’s not true; in the sense of economic coercion, well… there are a lot of jobs people don’t like and work because otherwise they wouldn’t eat. I think it’s kind of whorephobic to treat sex work as special because it’s ~~the sexysex. I mean. Unless you say retail workers or domestic laborers or coal miners are forced into it. 

I think this is about the context of Victor Hugo’s work. They’re forced into it because they have literally no other option. The book makes it very clear that this is a condemnation of the inequality of society and it’s meant as a mirror to the Jean Valjean story (essentially how upwards mobility is limited by gender). Prostitution was incredibly dangerous back then, even more so than it is now, and an early death was a given. In the context of the story, it’s roughly analogous to a man being forced to work in coal mines.

So it can seem whore-phobic from a modern perspective, but it’s really meant as a critique of an unequal society. It’s meant to show how ugly reality can be when people don’t have the social support to choose their own paths.

And this is also a very good point, along with Ozy’s.

  1. inuyashainterpretations reblogged this from brute-reason
  2. girlsforachange reblogged this from brute-reason and added:
    Did you line up to see...Miserables over the holiday break? Check out Ms Magazine’s post...
  3. ozyreads reblogged this from latining and added:
    Yes yes yes THAT. Playing Lovely Ladies as a funny song is… really not a good artistic choice. (Unless you’re going for...
  4. latining reblogged this from ozyreads and added:
    Yes, but I do see a lot of musicals glamorising survival sex work, so I read that as the writer critiquing the way the...
  5. brute-reason reblogged this from latining and added:
    And this is also a very good point, along with Ozy’s.
  6. worldwaswaking reblogged this from brute-reason
  7. vampirephotocoffeeshop reblogged this from brute-reason and added:
    Okay, so I haven’t seen the movie yet, but I disagree with the assessment that the musical is making light of the...
  8. felinejumper reblogged this from brute-reason and added:
    i think movie release merits a re-read of Les Mis.
  9. rachelari reblogged this from brute-reason and added:
    When I was a senior in college I decided if I ever got a masters or PhD in sociology I would write my thesis on 20th...
  10. textualcomplex reblogged this from brute-reason
  11. brute-reason posted this

blog comments powered by Disqus
Ultralite Powered by Tumblr | Designed by:Doinwork